1.8. Recommendations

Table 1.2: Guidelines for selecting optimal analysis method to use for a Brake Squeal problem

Analysis Method Benefits Costs
Linear non-prestressed modalFast run time

No convergence issues

Good method for performing parametric studies

Accuracy

Does not include pre-stress effects

Partial nonlinear perturbed modalNo convergence issues

Includes pre-stress effects

Accuracy
Full nonlinear perturbed modalAccurate

Includes pre-stress effects

Longer run time

Convergence issues


Table 1.3: Guidelines for Selecting the Optimal Eigensolver (MODOPT) for Obtaining the Brake Squeal solution

Eigensolver Benefits Costs
QRDAMP Fast run time

An excellent solver for performing parametric studies

Accuracy, as it approximates the unsymmetric stiffness matrix

Not recommended when the number of elements contributing to unsymmetric stiffness matrix exceeds 10 percent of the total number of elements in the model

UNSYM Accuracy, as it uses the full unsymmetric stiffness matrix to solve the problemLong run time when many modes are extracted

For further information, see Brake-Squeal (Prestressed Modal) Analysis in the Structural Analysis Guide.