VM-WB-MECH-104

VM-WB-MECH-104
Topology Optimization Benchmark Problem for Cantilever with End Load

Overview

Reference: Miguel A. Ochoa, S. Ivvan Valdez, Salvador Botello, Victor Cardoso. "Topology Optimization Benchmark I. Results for Minimum Compliance and Minimum Volume in Plane Stress Problems." 09.03.2016, I-16-01 (CC). Centro de Investigacion en Matematicas, A.C., Departamento de Ciencias Computatcionales Jalisco S/N, Col. Valenciana CP 36240 Guanajuato Gto., Mexico Technical Report, submitted on March 8, 2016 7.1: Cantilever with Load at Center (CLC).
Solver(s):

Ansys Mechanical and Topology Optimizer

Analysis Type(s): Static Structural and Topology Optimization
Element Type(s): PLANE183

Test Case

A cantilever beam of dimensions 2 m X 1 m is fixed at one end and a Force of 86000 N is applied on the center edge of beam (0.1 m) in a static structural analysis using plane stress. The model is optimized with the objective to minimize the compliance while using a volume constraint to keep 50 percent volume.

Figure 139: Structural Schematic

Structural Schematic

Material PropertiesGeometric PropertiesLoading
ASTM A-36 steelLength L = 2 m

Exclusion Boundary Condition = None

Young’s modulus E = 2.11e11 Pa

Width B = 1 m

Volume Response Constraint = 50%

Poisson’s ratio = 0.29Thickness = 0.01 mMinimum Member Size = 0.05 m
Mass density = 7874 kg/m3  
Yield Stress = 2.2e8 Pa  

Analysis Assumptions and Modeling Notes

The problem is solved using 2-D plane stress 8-node quadrilateral elements (PLANE183). To standardize the thickness and to fulfill the hypothesis of plane stress, the thickness used should be 1 percent of the maximum length size; in this problem, the thickness used for the surface body is 0.01 X 1 = 0.01 m. A minimum member size of 0.05 is specified.

Figure 140: Topological Optimization Setup

Topological Optimization Setup

Results Comparison

ResultTargetMechanicalError (%)
Final Volume (m3)1e-21.012e-21.160
Percent Volume of Original5050.5811.162
Compliance114.7114.70.0

Figure 141: Topology Optimized Design

Topology Optimized Design