VM284

VM284
Acceleration Solution in Response Spectrum Analysis Using Missing Mass Method

Overview

Reference:

Biswas, J.K, Duff, C.G., “Response Spectrum Method with Residual Terms”, ASME Publications, April 1978.

Analysis Type(s):
Modal Analysis (ANTYPE = 2)
Spectrum Analysis (ANTYPE = 8)
Element Type(s):
3D 2-Node Beam Element (BEAM188)
3D Structural Mass (MASS21)
Input Listing:vm284.dat

Test Case

Single point acceleration response spectrum analysis is performed on a vertical tank model that is 200 inches tall and 35 inches in diameter by exciting the structure in the global Z-direction. The tank is supported by a braced leg support and is filled with a fluid with a specific gravity of 1.57. The spectrum analysis is performed with the first four modes and missing mass to account for the higher modes. The modes are combined using the SRSS mode combination method and the absolute acceleration at different elevation points of the structure is obtained by summing the SRSS modal response with the absolute missing mass response. The accelerations are compared against the reference values shown in Column 9 of Table 1 in the reference document.

Figure 494: Problem Sketch of a Vertical Tank Model with Leg Supports

Problem Sketch of a Vertical Tank Model with Leg Supports

Figure 495: Frequency vs. Spectrum Values

Frequency vs. Spectrum Values

Material PropertiesGeometric PropertiesLoading
Tank
E = 2.9 x 107 lb/in2
ν = 0.3
Density = 0.000724638 lb-sec2/in4
Specific gravity of fluid = 1.57
Leg support
Area = 10 in2
Moment of inertia = 2250 in3
Structural mass = 982/386.4 lb
Tank
Inner radius = 17.5 in
Outer radius = 18.1 in
Thickness = 0.6 in
Height = 180 in
Leg support

Height = 20 in

Frequency vs. spectrum curve, refer to Figure 495: Frequency vs. Spectrum Values.

Analysis Assumptions and Modeling Notes

The vertical tank is modeled with 3D 2-Node Beam Elements (BEAM188) with quadratic shape function and with circular tube cross section. The leg support is modeled with 3D 2-Node beam elements (BEAM188) with arbitrary cross section. The structural mass is equally distributed for the tank using MASS21 elements. The mass is determined from the specific gravity of the fluid and the volume of the tank. The first four modes are obtained using the Block-Lanczos eigensolver and these modes, along with the missing mass with ZPA value of 0.5, are used in the spectrum analysis to determine the absolute acceleration of the structure.

Results Comparison

Elevation (in)Absolute Acceleration (g)Ratio
TargetMechanical APDL
00.5000.5001.01
200.5400.5151.05
400.6260.5991.04
600.7470.7241.03
800.9150.9660.95
1001.2881.2901.00
1201.6341.5871.03
1401.9491.8651.04
1602.2452.1321.05
1802.5782.4741.04
2003.0062.8651.05