56.7. Results and Discussion

The following figures show the equivalent stress and total mechanical equivalent strain plots following the 2-D axisymmetric analysis.

Figure 56.10: Equivalent Stress After 2-D Axisymmetric Analysis

Equivalent Stress After 2-D Axisymmetric Analysis

Figure 56.11: Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After 2-D Axisymmetric Analysis

Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After 2-D Axisymmetric Analysis

The following figures show the equivalent stress and total equivalent strain plots on the extruded 3-D model after mapping (MAP2DTO3D,SOLVE):

Figure 56.12: Equivalent Stress After MAP2DTO3D

Equivalent Stress After MAP2DTO3D

Figure 56.13: Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After MAP2DTO3D

Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After MAP2DTO3D

As expected, the results closely match those of the corresponding 2-D model. Results may differ, however, if contact settings are not equivalent in the 2-D and extruded 3-D models. In such cases, experiment with the contact settings to obtain matching results. This includes tightening the penetration tolerances for the contact pairs or changing the contact formulation and the detection method used.

The following figures show the equivalent stress and total mechanical equivalent strain plots on the 3-D model after solving for the bending load via the multiframe restart analysis.

Figure 56.14: Equivalent Stress After Restart Analysis with Bending Load

Equivalent Stress After Restart Analysis with Bending Load

Figure 56.15: Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After Restart Analysis with Bending Load

Total Mechanical Equivalent Strain After Restart Analysis with Bending Load

The following figure shows the bending stress plot on threads after solving the 3-D model with bending load.

Figure 56.16: Bending Stress on the Threads After 3-D Analysis

Bending Stress on the Threads After 3-D Analysis

This figure shows the contact pressure plot on the threaded region for the 3-D model after mapping (MAP2DTO3D,SOLVE):

Figure 56.17: Contact Pressure at the Threaded Connection After MAP2DTO3D

Contact Pressure at the Threaded Connection After MAP2DTO3D

As expected, the contact pressure is uniform in the circumferential direction.

The contact pressure plot on the threaded region at the end of the analysis is shown below.

Figure 56.18: Contact Pressure at the Threaded Connection

Contact Pressure at the Threaded Connection

Due to bending, the threaded connection bears most of the load on one side.